For a beginner, the individual horse matters more than the breed: a mature, well-schooled, calm and sound horse with experience of riders, vetted by an independent vet before purchase, while the rider learns with a qualified instructor. The British Horse Society (BHS) advises first-time owners and developing riders to avoid very young, unbacked or “green” horses. The breeds in this article are only examples, not a recommendation. This is general information, not veterinary advice.
Why the horse matters more than the breed
The British government’s code of practice for the welfare of horses (DEFRA, 2017) lists what a prospective owner should weigh up: the horse’s age, breed, gender, intended use and level of training, and whether the horse is a suitable size for the rider’s height and weight. The code is British, so treat it as good practice, not as Slovenian or Croatian rules. It suggests trying a number of horses, always seeking the advice of an experienced horseperson, and having the horse examined by an independent vet before purchase.
Breed differences are real: a guide from Utah State University Extension (2007) notes that some breeds tend to be more high-spirited, while others are known for calmness and ease of handling. Yet for a first horse, breed is a poor guide. Purdue University’s guide to selecting a first horse (1993) states that every breed has calm, quiet horses as well as anxious, dangerous ones, and that training and handling affect manners more than breed does. A review by Thompson, McGreevy and McManus (Animals, 2015) says there is evidence of breed differences in personality but little guidance on using it to reduce risk, and that there is no widely accepted, validated way of assessing experience when deciding which horse and rider make a safe combination.
You are not looking for a breed with a good reputation, but for a horse that has already done what you are still learning.
A difficult temperament can also point to a health problem. In a study by Fureix, Menguy and Hausberger (PLoS ONE, 2010), 33 of 43 horses with severe vertebral problems reacted aggressively towards people (against 9 of 16 horses with no or slight problems). The authors warn that chronic discomfort or pain is often overlooked in “bad-tempered” animals. This shows an association, not the cause in any one horse, but it is a good reason to treat the pre-purchase examination as more than a formality.
Green horse, green rider
The BHS guide to buying a horse says first-time owners and developing riders are best off avoiding very young, unbacked or “green” horses, which often need consistent, experienced handling and training that can feel overwhelming without support. By the BHS definition, a green horse has limited experience of being ridden or handled and is still learning the basics. Its opposite is the schoolmaster: an experienced horse that knows its job and is often calm, forgiving and consistent, helping a rider to grow. Purdue is blunter: inexperienced owners and young horses are a dangerous combination.
The figures show why the early stage is risky. In a survey of 679 equestrians in Oregon, Washington and Idaho in the United States (Mayberry et al., Journal of Trauma, 2007), the incidence of any injury per 10,000 hours of horse-related activity was 7.6 for novices, 2.4 for intermediate riders, 1.5 for advanced riders and 1.0 for professionals. The authors estimate that about 100 hours of experience are needed before injuries fall substantially. The data are from a US survey, so treat them as a guide, not a forecast.
A green horse and an inexperienced rider are a risky combination:
- the BHS says first-time owners and developing riders are best off avoiding very young, unbacked or “green” horses
- do not buy a horse unseen: the BHS and World Horse Welfare both advise against it, and the BHS also cautions about auctions, where there is little chance to view and try the horse
- wear a well-fitting riding hat, fastened, every time you ride (BHS); the BHS says no hat can be guaranteed to protect every rider in every circumstance; the editors recommend that a beginner learns with a qualified instructor
- for a child the same logic applies: the USU guide advises against buying a young horse for a young rider; more in A pony or horse for a child
Age, schooling and sex
The BHS advises a horse with steady experience of being ridden, without naming an age. For amateurs and novices Purdue recommends a horse of 6 to 12 years, adding that a horse under five that is trained and quiet enough would be rare. By that guide the reason lies in the schooling, calmness and experience that age brings, not in age itself. That US guide is old, so the range is only indicative. An older horse is not risk-free either: according to the BHS, first signs of ageing often appear in a horse’s mid to late teens, and arthritis is more common in older horses. The DEFRA code says to expect ongoing costs to rise as a horse ages.
More schooling is not automatically better. Purdue warns that a highly schooled horse can be so responsive that a novice confuses it and gets no response, or gets more response than wanted and the rider is hurt. So a horse schooled to your level and consistent in everyday tasks serves a beginner better than the most polished one.
On sex, both guides are cautious. Purdue says mares and geldings are the only good choices for people with limited experience, and USU says a stallion should never be considered by a novice owner. The authors of Aune et al. (Animals, 2020) report that riders prefer geldings; in their survey of 1,233 owner responses, ridden behaviour showed no significant differences between mares and geldings, although mares were more likely to move away when being caught. These are owner reports, so sex is only one clue.
What to look for
From the DEFRA code, the BHS and World Horse Welfare guides and the university handbooks you can build a checklist for each horse:
| Quality | Good sign | What to watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Experience | Steady experience of being ridden (BHS) | A green, unbacked or very young horse (BHS) |
| History | As full as possible: why it is sold, health, previous homes and work (World Horse Welfare) | An unknown or vague history |
| On the ground | A kind eye, curiosity and willingness to interact are often good signs (BHS) | Behaviour when caught in, groomed and tacked up (BHS) |
| Ridden | The horse’s training and confidence complement your own (BHS) | Too forward may dent confidence, too quiet may not inspire you (BHS) |
| Health | Independent vet examination (BHS, DEFRA) | Lameness or pain that may only show under saddle (Dyson) |
| Size | Suits your height and weight (DEFRA) | A horse too small or too big for the rider |
| Seller | Patient and open (BHS) | Reluctance to show loading, distracting the horse, no passport (BHS) |
Small is not the same as easy: even a small horse weighs several hundred kilograms, and according to our Icelandic horse profile a small height does not mean the horse suits everyone.

Trying the horse and vetting
According to the BHS, a pre-purchase veterinary examination (a “vetting”) assesses whether a horse has existing health conditions that may affect your intended use, and it is not a guarantee of future health, because a vet can only assess the horse’s condition on the day of the vetting. Tell the vet what you plan to do, arrange the examination yourself and use your own or an independent vet, not the seller’s. You can search the directory for vets for horses in Slovenia.
According to Dyson (Animals, 2026), lameness and canter problems may only be apparent during ridden exercise, yet ridden assessment of gait quality is not a routine part of pre-purchase examinations; the BHS lists ridden exercise in its five-stage vetting, but to raise the horse’s heart and breathing rate. The study covered only 25 sports horses, so this is a reason to ask your vet about ridden assessment, not a rule. What a vetting costs depends on its scope, the area and the vet; for a cost framework see How much does a horse cost.
How to try a horse, following the BHS and DEFRA:
- Several viewings: see the horse more than once because first impressions can change, and keep notes after each viewing
- Everyday tasks: watch how the horse behaves when caught in from the field, groomed, tacked up and handled
- Seller rides first: then you ride the type of riding you plan to do (a trainer beside you is the editors’ recommendation); ask about hacking and riding in groups too
- Trial period: if the seller offers one, get everything agreed in writing; a trial can also be arranged with the horse staying at the seller’s yard
- Vet: arrange the pre-purchase examination yourself, with an independent vet
Breeds as examples: conditional, not a recommendation
Our breed profiles rate suitability for beginners as “conditional” for all seven breeds below. The reason is not a flaw in the breeds: as the points above show, the horse, its schooling and professional help decide.
| Breed | What the profile says |
|---|---|
| Haflinger | A well-schooled, calm horse and an experienced instructor |
| Icelandic horse | A reliable, calm horse; an instructor who knows gaited horses |
| Connemara pony | A schooled, calm pony and regular lessons |
| Welsh pony and cob | A young or inconsistently schooled pony soon takes the initiative |
| Lipizzaner | A calm adult horse and an experienced trainer; the breed matures late |
| Arabian horse | An older, calm horse; a young one is generally not a beginner’s horse |
| American Quarter Horse | An older, quiet horse; a highly responsive competition horse is unsuitable |
For the Haflinger the profile says a young or poorly schooled horse can, despite its breed, have a will and strength a novice struggles to manage. For the Icelandic horse it quotes the Slovenian society DRIKS, who say it is not by nature a horse for children and inexperienced riders, while adding that sources differ and the individual horse decides. For the Lipizzaner it says the horse is highly sensitive and remembers rough or inconsistent handling just as well, so a well-schooled horse and a trainer beside the rider are decisive. For the Arabian it points to quick reactions to the surroundings. For the Quarter Horse it says a young, unschooled or highly responsive competition horse is not a beginner’s horse, whatever its breed.
Ponies are similar. For the Connemara the profile says a schooled, calm pony and regular lessons with a trainer matter more than breed. The sizes of the Welsh pony sections are compared in A pony or horse for a child. Nor is a pony automatically easier: Purdue writes that small children are better off on a quiet larger horse than on a small, wild pony.
Have a trainer beside you from the start
The BHS suggests bringing a trusted coach or knowledgeable friend to viewings: they may notice details you miss, and a second viewing lets you reflect together. DEFRA advises always seeking the advice of an experienced horseperson, and USU that an inexperienced buyer should ask a more experienced person to help evaluate horses. The DEFRA code adds that considering your own riding skills, and improving them, helps reduce the risk of the horse developing behavioural problems when ridden.
You can find trainers in the online register of professional staff kept by the Slovenian equestrian federation (Konjeniška zveza Slovenije, KZS) and in the list of licensed trainers and riding instructors published by the Croatian Equestrian Federation (HKS); more in How to start horse riding.
Loan or lease as a trial step
You can also get to know horses before buying by taking lessons, renting a horse at camps or parks, or leasing a horse and keeping it elsewhere (Purdue). The BHS writes that horses used for novice riders are good-natured and quiet, and that its approved centres have qualified staff. On loan, DEFRA points out that the responsibilities and ongoing costs are the same as owning. More on preparing for ownership is in What you need before buying your first horse.
Frequently asked questions
Is a Haflinger suitable for a beginner?
It can be, but only with conditions. The breed profile says the horse must be well schooled and calm, and the rider must progress under an experienced instructor. The breed is selected for a calm, dependable temperament, but a young or poorly schooled Haflinger can show a will and strength a novice struggles to manage. More in the Haflinger profile.
Is a Lipizzaner suitable for a beginner?
It can be as a calm, well-schooled adult horse with regular work under an experienced trainer. The profile stresses that the breed matures late and remembers bad experiences, so a young or poorly schooled horse is not the right choice for an inexperienced owner. Read the Lipizzaner profile.
Is an Arabian horse suitable for a beginner?
Conditionally. An older, well-schooled, calm Arabian can make a good schoolmaster if the novice rides under a trainer. A young or unschooled one reacts quickly to its surroundings and copes badly with inconsistent or rough handling. The profile adds that the individual horse and professional support count for more than the breed label. More in the Arabian horse profile.
How old should a beginner’s horse be?
There is no common figure. The BHS advises a horse with steady experience of being ridden; Purdue (1993) gives 6 to 12 years for novices but sees the reason in schooling and experience, not in age itself. An older horse may need more health care, so a vet should examine it before purchase.
Mare, stallion or gelding?
Purdue advises beginners to choose a mare or gelding, while USU advises against a stallion for an inexperienced owner. The survey by Aune et al. (2020) found no significant differences in ridden behaviour between mares and geldings, so sex is only one clue alongside the experience and schooling of the individual horse. The data are owner reports.
Should a first horse be a pony?
Not necessarily. DEFRA advises a horse whose size suits the rider’s height and weight, and our Icelandic horse profile warns that small height does not mean an animal suits everyone. Sizes within a pony breed are compared in A pony or horse for a child. Choose the size to fit the rider; calmness counts for more than centimetres.
Who should help me choose a horse?
A qualified trainer and an independent vet. The BHS advises bringing a trainer or experienced friend to viewings and having the pre-purchase examination done by a vet who is not the seller’s. DEFRA adds that the advice of an experienced horseperson should always be sought, and the directory on Živalce lists vets who care for horses.
This article is general advice and does not replace a visit to the vet. If your animal is ill, injured or getting worse, talk to a vet as soon as you can.
Related to this article
Read next
The article is just the start. Care for your pet every day. 🐾
On Živalce.si you can create a free profile for your pet, keep its journal, track measurements and set the reminders that matter.
Everything important about your pet in one place.
Sources and photos
- Guide to buying a horse: questions to ask and more — British Horse Society (BHS) (accessed: 29.09.2026)
- Pre Purchase Veterinary Examination — British Horse Society (BHS) (accessed: 29.09.2026)
- Code of practice for the welfare of horses, ponies, donkeys and their hybrids — DEFRA (UK Government) (accessed: 29.09.2026)
- Buying or selling a horse: top tips — World Horse Welfare (accessed: 29.09.2026)
- Learning to ride — British Horse Society (BHS) (accessed: 29.09.2026)
- Horse riding helmets: fitting & safety — British Horse Society (BHS) (accessed: 29.09.2026)
- Care of elderly horses — British Horse Society (BHS) (accessed: 29.09.2026)
- AS-465 Selecting the first horse — Purdue University Cooperative Extension Service (accessed: 29.09.2026)
- Buying your first horse — Utah State University Extension (accessed: 29.09.2026)
- Equestrian injury prevention efforts need more attention to novice riders — Mayberry JC et al., Journal of Trauma 62(3), 2007 (accessed: 29.09.2026)
- A Critical Review of Horse-Related Risk: A Research Agenda for Safer Mounts, Riders and Equestrian Cultures — Thompson K, McGreevy P, McManus P. Animals 5(3), 2015 (accessed: 29.09.2026)
- Partners with bad temper: reject or cure? A study of chronic pain and aggression in horses — Fureix C, Menguy H, Hausberger M. PLoS ONE 5(8), 2010 (accessed: 29.09.2026)
- Reported Behavioural Differences between Geldings and Mares Challenge Sex-Driven Stereotypes in Ridden Equine Behaviour — Aune A et al. Animals 10(3), 2020 (accessed: 29.09.2026)
- An Investigation of the Role of Ridden Exercise, Including Application of the Ridden Horse Pain Ethogram, in Pre-Purchase Examinations of Sports Horses — Dyson S. Animals 16(13), 2026 (accessed: 29.09.2026)
- Register of professional staff — KZS (Slovenian equestrian federation) (accessed: 29.09.2026)
- Licensed trainers and riding instructors — HKS (Croatian Equestrian Federation) (accessed: 29.09.2026)
Photos
- Author: holger mohaupt · CC BY-SA 3.0 · source: Wikimedia Commons
- Author: Clemens Stockner · CC BY-SA 4.0 · source: Wikimedia Commons